DIY मीडिया होम लोगो

अपनी खुद की होम थिएटर और हाय-Fi सेटअप डिजाइन और बनाने के लिए परम साइट.

3मीडिया प्लेयर शास्त्रीय - होम सिनेमा लोगोMadvr GPU प्रदर्शन की तुलना करना

मेरी मौजूदा किराया HTPC has an nVidia GeForce GTX 1050Ti 4Gb with which I am able to upscale all con­tent to 1080p with fairly high qual­ity set­tings, और भी हूँ (केवल) able to play­back 8k 60fps con­tent down­scaled to 1080p. कैसे कभी, I have long wondered what the bene­fits of a more power­ful card might be on the abil­ity to use high­er set­tings. उदासी से, no-one seems to provide any bench­marks for mad­vr, तो कार्ड की तुलना कैसे की जा सकती है?

After much search­ing, it seems that the strongest indic­at­or of mad­vr per­form­ance is the shader per­form­ance of a card. This is effect­ively meas­ured in FLOPS. There are some lim­it­a­tions to this as a doub­ling of shader per­form­ance does­n’t necesar­ily mean a halv­ing of render time so the rela­tion­ship isn’t necesar­ily lin­ear, but once oth­er factors (उदा.. memory quant­ity and speed) बराबर हैं, the shader per­form­ance will be a good guide to the per­form­ance of a card.

It is highly recom­men­ded to get a GPU with at least 4Gb of VRAM for mad­vr. Assum­ing a new card is being obtained, मेमोरी कम से कम GDDR5 होने की संभावना है, और अच्छी तरह से GDDR6 हो सकता है. In these cir­cum­stances the shader per­form­ance is a use­ful guide.

I also used a few spe­cif­ic pieces of inform­a­tion to com­pare dif­fer­ent bench­marks to see which type appeared to be the best fit. जानकारी का एक टुकड़ा मैंने उठाया है कि मेरी 1050टीआई Radeon RX से तेज है 570 in mad­vr which is not reflec­ted in lots of GPU com­pute bench­marks which sug­gests these are not a good type of bench­mark to use.

Anoth­er dir­ect com­par­is­on sug­gests that the 1060Ti is faster in mad­vr than the RX580 so this should also be reflec­ted in any bench­marks used, जो उनमें से अधिकांश को नियंत्रित करता है! In the same thread there is a sug­ges­tion that the Radeon RX 5700 XT is sim­il­ar in per­form­ance to a GeForce RTX 2070 Super

Some oth­er facts from the doom9 for­ums

  • AMD RX480 GTX970 की तुलना में थोड़ा तेज है
  • GTX1070 के आसपास है 30% RX480 की तुलना में तेज़

As I was­n’t able to find any bench­mark that matched these data points, instead I’ve star­ted by look­ing at all the cards avail­able in the £100 — £200 brack­et which are…

  • GTX 1660 £ 195
  • RX590 £ 190
  • RX5500 XT £ 160
  • GTX 1650 सुपर £ 150
  • RX580 £ 145
  • GTX 1050Ti £ 130

Is there a sur­pris­ing win­ner, or does the price pre­dict the performance?

The info I can find sug­gests that the GTX 1650 (सुपर नहीं) है चारों ओर 25% तेजी than the GTX 1050Ti in mad­vr, और 1650 सुपर फिर से तेज है (more cuda cores and a high­er clock speed). यह भी प्रकट होता है RX5700 XT है थोड़ा सा तेज GTX की तुलना में 1080 और वह RX5700 (एक्सटी नहीं) is sim­il­ar to a GTX 1070.

After lots of search­ing to com­pare these cards I found a very use­ful post on red­dit which ranks the nVidia cards approx­im­ately. These rank­ings (unsur­pris­ingly) do fol­low the price of the nVidia cards.

  • GTX 1050 / 1050 ती
  • GTX 1650
  • GTX 1650 Super
  • GTX 1060
  • GTX 1070/1660 / 1660 उत्तम / 1660 ती
  • GTX 1080 / RX 2060
  • GTX 1080Ti / RTX 2070

The bet­ter cards (towards the bot­tom) tend to be bey­ond the price range. मैं एक GTX देख सकता हूं 1070 लगभग £ 230 के लिए eBay पर जो एक नए GTX से अधिक है 1660 इसलिए सेकंड हैंड विकल्प मदद के लिए प्रकट नहीं होते हैं. EBay पर £ 170 के आसपास 6GB GTX 1060 भी हैं (3Gb पर्याप्त नहीं है, 4Gb is a min­im­um really so be care­ful with these) — but are they really £20 bet­ter than a new GTX 1650 Super?

It sounds like the AMD Polar­is gen­er­a­tion cards wer­en’t good per­formers in mad­vr. This has appar­ently changed with Navi, how­ever there have been driver issues with Navi so most people still recom­mend nVidia cards for mad­vr. On top of this it is rumoured that future ver­sions of mad­vr may make use of the nVidia tur­ing archi­tec­ture, but these rumours are at least a year old with noth­ing to show so far. If they ever come true it may be that AMD’s “ray-tra­cing” com­pat­ible cards may be just as well suited too.

I have a sus­pi­cion that the RX 5500 XT एक अच्छा मूल्य सौदा हो सकता है क्योंकि यह GTX की पेशकश कर सकता है 1660 like per­form­ance in mad­vr, £ 35 कम के लिए, but I can­’t find con­crete evid­ence or a dir­ect comparison.

उत्तर छोड़ दें

3 टिप्पणियाँ


Does­n’t the 1070 है 6+ tflops where­as the 1660 केवल है 5 TFlops? Would­n’t this make the 1070 bet­ter for mad­vr, espe­cially when the 1070 comes with 8gb of memory?

जवाब दें
जेएसजॉन Scaife

Pos­sibly so, altho my guess is that the dif­fer­ence isn’t big enough to enable any addi­tion­al set­tings in mad­vr so may be irrel­ev­ant. The tflops score does­n’t appear to per­fectly pre­dict mad­vr per­form­ance. The only way to know for sure would be to test both but I haven’t found any­where doing dir­ect com­par­is­ons of cards in madvr.

जवाब दें