0PSU LogoPSU Efficiency: worth the upgrade? part 3

This is the third install­ment in a series of art­icles address­ing PSU effi­ciency.  Art­icle one focused on a the­or­et­ic­al new serv­er, art­icle 2 on a typ­ic­al desktop PC.  This art­icle will focus on a cur­rent real serv­er, and intro­duces a new PSU — an 80+ plat­in­um model.

The sys­tem spends a lot of time semi-idling (serving net­work and disk requests but not doing too much CPU work).  I estim­ated that it would pull around 150W on aver­age, and then cal­cu­lated it below.  It really did come out exactly like that!
Base sys­tem Sem­pron LE-1100 (1.9GHz single-core) on nForce 630i / 7050 mother­board.  2Gb DDR-II35W
2x Sam­sung F4 2Tb HDDs, 7x 1Tb Green HDDs inc. WD Green 1Tb, Seag­ate 1Tb and Sam­sung 1Tb, 1x WD 750Gb 7200rpm drive, 1x Max­tor 300Gb 7200rpm drive, 1x WD 200Gb 7200rpm IDE drive108W
Areca 1220 RAID Card5W
2x 120mm Case Fan2W

Out of interest, assum­ing a cost of £0.10 per kWh this sys­tem would cost a total of £131.50 a year to run even with a per­fectly effi­cient PSU!

The ATX spe­cific­a­tion requires 70% effi­ciency.  Below is a com­par­is­on between a bare min­im­um ATX PSU and a few highly effi­cient PSU’s.

The fig­ure for the gen­er­ic PSU is based on the min­im­um require­ment and is there­fore a worst case.  I have cal­cu­lated a best-case yearly sav­ing, based on a kWh charge of 10p and assum­ing 24.7 usage.

Make / ModelEffi­ciency at 150WEst. A.C. power drawSav­ing
ATX v2.2 250w ATX70% (at 150W)215W
Season­ic X‑40088.8%169W£40.39
Cor­sair AX85087.4%172W£38.02
Ener­max Modu87+ 500w88.5%169W£39.89
Cor­sair CX400W82.1%183W£28.31
King­win Lazer Plat­in­um 550W93.3%161W£47.54
HuntKey Jump­er R90 300W 80+ Gold90%167W£41.74

Con­clu­sion: This is the first scen­ario where new high­er-effi­ciency PSUs are reas­on­ably price com­pet­it­ive based only on power usage.  For such a sys­tem, a high effi­ciency PSU will pay for itself with­in approx­im­ately 3 years.  If you plan to keep the sys­tem for more than 3 years a high effi­ciency PSU is a worth­while invest­ment as its TCO will be lower.  As energy prices con­tin­ue to rise this TCO advant­age will widen.

Update (25-Dec-2011)

Added the HuntKey Jump­er R90.  This PSU changes the con­clu­sion con­clus­ively.  It pro­duces sav­ings of over £40, which is at least the price of the PSU!  A pay­back peri­od of 1 year, with an expect­a­tion that elec­tri­city prices will con­tin­ue to rise is well worth the investment.

Please send us your thoughts by commenting below! If you would like to subscribe please use the subscribe link on the menu at the top right. You can also share this with your friends by using the social links below. Cheers.

Leave a Reply